mudroomaddition

Soaking Tub v. Shallow Tub?

mudroomaddition
4 years ago

I am replacing an alcove bathtub in my teenagers bathroom. It is the only bathtub in our home. The dimensions will be 30x60. The current tub is a bit less than 9 inches of water depth. My kids mostly use the shower, but I would like to replace it with a deeper tub (at least 12 inches of water depth) so taking a bath is an option - but I realize that will mean a higher "step" to get in the shower. (We are a pretty tall family - so taking a bath in the current bathtub doesn't work well). Any advice on tub option? Anyone regret getting a "soaking" tub that is used for a shower as well? Thank you!

Comments (10)

  • Greg Bennin
    4 years ago

    Get on Kohlers website or home depot to start. Note how many gallons your water heater is and don't go much over 30% of that. I put a 110 gallon soaking tub in a new house and needed 2 40 gallon water heaters to make sure it'd be warm enough.

    mudroomaddition thanked Greg Bennin
  • mudroomaddition
    Original Author
    4 years ago

    Thanks Greg. I did not think about the water heater. I was worried about stepping into the tub with the additional height.

  • smit2380
    4 years ago

    We just installed a deep tub (like 21 inches) in a hall bath like that. We like it, but I am 5’2” and it is a big step. We added a grab bar to go with it.

    mudroomaddition thanked smit2380
  • PRO
    Rustica Hardware
    4 years ago

    I take baths a lot, so I feel like a soaking tub is the way to go! I have a soaking tub in my home and the step in has never bothered me.

    mudroomaddition thanked Rustica Hardware
  • PRO
    User
    4 years ago

    If the primary use is as a shower, your choice will need to be tilted to that function. Look at the American Standard tubs who have the overflows at the top of the opening, like shown below, instead of down in the tub. That gives you a few more inches of soak room, while still maintaining the lower side needed for use as an everyday shower. You will require one with an integral tiling flange for use as a tub shower.




    mudroomaddition thanked User
  • PRO
    Norwood Architects
    4 years ago

    Soaking tub for sure.

  • K R
    4 years ago

    We replaced a kids’ alcove tub with a deep Kohler underscore tub during the remodel. Both of my kids are tall (girl is 5’6” and boy is 6’) and they both enjoy taking showers and baths in this tub.

  • Maria Mesgar
    4 years ago

    KR what material is this.? Price point...

  • worthy
    4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    We have a couple of 17.5" high acrylic tubs and until your posting I never thought twice about it being a high step-in nor recall any complaints from others. (And they're not shy about voicing their opinions.)