skip to main content

Butcher Block vs Granite Counter tops?

Christine Bouvier

11 years ago

I am embarking on a new build, and I am very interested in butcher block counter top for the island. Please help me with pros and cons.

Featured Answer

PRO

Craft Art Elegant Surfaces

9 years ago

Great question. Because our wood countertops are waterproof, stain resistant and food safe they are a great addition to the kitchen or even bathroom. Most of our customers choose to actually use BOTH granite or other stone in the SAME kitchen as a wood countertop. Mixing surfaces is the most popular trend we have seen in high end kitchen countertops/design recently. The key is truly in the finish used on the wood.

Why It's Waterproof:

http://www.craft-art.com/why-craft-art-wood-countertops-are-waterproof/

Daily maintenance of our wood tops is very similar to granite. Clean with a mixture of white vinegar & water or a mild soap/detergent that contains no bleach or ammonia (just like granite!). Every 3 to 5 years if water stops beading up on the surface then you can simply reapply one coat of Waterlox.
Check out the video(s) here: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCAxe-rC_5mg37uKLwb2DoxQ

How to Clean Craft Art Butcherblock Wood Countertops:

For a busy household some people choose to add our Distressing option so that scratches (which can naturally will happen over time) are disguised. I’ve included photos of distressed and non Distressed below.

All of our wood species fall within a range of hardness that is best suited for countertop use. For example a 10’x5’ island would be made with full 10 foot long boards so that you do not have a choppy “hard wood floor” look. Each countertop is custom made to order and the boards go from lumber to the finished product in about 14 business days.

You should definitely test water, red wine, mustard etc on a sample to see in person. https://store.craft-art.com/product-category/samples/organic-tung-oil-finish-samples/

I’ve attached lots of photos with our wood tops to help inspire you!

(Photo Credits:
1. Mrs. Benink - homeowner- submitted photo, Black Walnut plank style with Farm sink
2. Photo submitted by homeowner who wished to not be named Black Walnut Plank style countertop.
3. Design by Classic Cabinetry (Christy) TN - Distressed Black Walnut Plank wood island countertop with undermount sink.
4. Beech edge grain - photo and countertop by Craft Art)

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (19)

PRO
Ironwood Builders
11 years ago
last modified: 11 years ago
I like butcher block, especially when it is NOT at the sink or range. An island with a butcher block top sounds great. Pros are: you can use it for a cutting board and food prep and if it stains, pull out your sander and clean it off. It looks good, adding color and texture to the horizontal plane of the kitchen. It is pretty low maintenance, needing a coat of mineral oil about once a year. Cons? You mess it up using it for a cutting board and food prep and need to sand out stains. It is a little busy, color and texture wise for some kitchens. It takes maintenance, needing mineral oil about once a year. Oh, and water and grease are kinda bad for it, so keeping the sink and range away from the wood is good. Not being snide at all, the pros really are cons for some people!
PRO
Linda Mayo
11 years ago
last modified: 11 years ago
There are quite a few woods available for butcher block which is a plus. If you buy one from Craft-Art it comes sealed with tongue oil and they do not recommend cutting on it.They do suggest that their countertops can be used in a sink area so if you want to put an island sink in, you should be able to. They are beautiful. Here is a link to their site, showing species and layups. http://www.craft-art.com/wood-species/

I too like the idea that they can be sanded down and refinished.
Related Discussions
1940's NZ kitchen - small, awkward-ish layout.
Q
Comments (121)
I would suggest you take out the cabinet that is to the right of the stove and use it elsewhere in the house -- perhaps in the bathroom or dining room with a hutch above it. Then, I would suggest you have someone install a lazy susan cabinet in the corner between the sink counter and the stove, meaning you would move the stove down a bit and have a small cabinet/counter top to the right of the stove. I would suggest you have the cabinets refinished in white and then paint the walls a pastel you like. If you would prefer white walls, then add white-painted crown molding and paint the ceiling a light neutral blue, such as Sherwin Williams Niagara Falls Blue. Then, I would suggest you choose a favorite accent color and use this sparingly in accessories like towels, pot holders, small vases or floral arrangements, and a valence above the triple windows. For a genuine 1940s look, you might have white ceramic square tiles with a rectangular red border installed as a back splash behind and above the stove. If you are replacing counter tops, I would suggest a light color such as white with a beige or light grey vein or striation for some sort of pattern. You might be able to find the same color and design in floor tile OR opt for a wood floor as another poster suggested.
...See More
Building a new house - kitchen help please
Q
Comments (40)
We got the IKEA shelves that are pictured in the butlers pantry photo I posted when we were on holiday in Melbourne, Australia. We don't have IKEA here in New Zealand! Hubby is going back over in May/June so will get him to get more of that sort of thing when there. We would pay about 4x the price for that sort of thing here in NZ. I need to work out what I will do now where the fridge was and there is the angle change (does that make sense?).
...See More
Kitchen bench top
Q
Comments (1)
How about butcher block instead? IKEA and the big box stores sell it for countertops, the price is decent, and you won't have as many issues with buckling, water damage, or what to do with the edge as you would with the ply. If the edges of the ply get wet, or if any seam around a sink gets wet, the plywood will "blow" and you will have to replace it all, anyway.
...See More
Need help with my kitchen
Q
Comments (19)
congrats! first, sand prime and paint out those cabinets....i'd go with a grayish shade of white or pale gray that will work with the flooring. i'd also carefuly chip off the yellow tiles. since on a budget, consider applying some beadboard as your backsplash, painted in a glossy, oil based or marine paint in a crisp white to keep it scrubbable, then, dress up the edges with some small mouldings, painted in the same white paint. this is going to be SO MUCH less costly than tile! and it will look great with the butcher block countertop. you can probably refresh the butcher block with a light sand and oiling. you could even get an additional piece of butcher block (ikea) and create a step-up 'bar' for some stools on the peninsula for some casual seating. then get a pair of pendant lights to hang from the pot lights above (they make lights that insert directly into the pot light...no hardwire necessary).
...See More
PRO
Pyramid Design Group Architects
11 years ago
Butcher block is not as sanitary as granite. Also butcher vlock might be a little dated, if you are thinking of future resale .
PRO
Dytecture
11 years ago
Here is an example of a movable butcher block on top of a solid counter surface which could provide you with the best of both worlds.

Kitchen · More Info
PRO
Riddle Construction & Design
11 years ago
I love wood tops and don't think they are dated at all. They are warmer than stone or quartz and offer a different design element instead of so many cold surfaces present in todays kitchens. That said, I do suggest that our clients do not use them as cutting boards but treat them more as you would a wood surface on a piece of furniture. They can dent and scratch over time but they can be re-sanded and refinished easily. See this Lyptus wood top we did below.
PRO
Riddle Construction & Design
11 years ago
Lyptus wood countertop
PRO
Riddle Construction & Design
11 years ago
Lyptus wood top
PRO
TJP Designs and Construction LLC
11 years ago
It's good to break up the surface areas in the kitchen with the use of alternate surface products and colors, and makes for a more interesting kitchen!!!!
PRO
All Island Group
11 years ago
A granite top would make cleaning much easier. You can purchase a butchers block as Dytecture picture shows. You'll have the option of both!
PRO
One Specialty Landscape Design, Pools & Hardscape
11 years ago
Go with granite or quartz for counters, opt for butcher block on an island! I don't think the butcher block look is dated at all and some butcher blocks feature a stripe in the middle with a darker wood. Love this look!
PRO
Rustica Hardware
11 years ago
last modified: 11 years ago
Wood butcher blocks look great in kitchens. I agree with what Ironwood Builders said about them. A good source for butcher countertops online is Chop Bloc see: http://chopbloccuttingboards.com/butcher-block-countertops/
Juli
11 years ago
All my kitchen counters are butcher block.. That said, I agree fully with the first comment! What I love about is also what I hate. I guess if I were to do it again I would keep the island and replace counters. I don't use them as a cutting board, however, often Company does so be sure you lay down the rules before you let someone loose in your kitchen! I've had them completely sanded and refinished once, to the tune of about 800 bucks...they need it again....
PRO
JDM Countertops, Inc.
11 years ago
I agree with everyone suggesting a multi surface kitchen. That way you can have both looks, and do on one what you cannot do on the other. Island block and quartz/granite for the perimeter. Both stone and wood are porous and need different kinds of maintenance (unless you use engineered stone), but using the two together will provide a nice balance and contrast to each other.
PRO
Linda Mayo
11 years ago
last modified: 11 years ago
People have been using wood surfaces for cooking, wood bowls and utensils for thousands of years.

Countertops that are glued together with the edge up (straight grain on side) are harder.
PRO
Where Wood Meets Steel
11 years ago
We have an 8' maple butcher block island (custom built by John Boos) with an elevated granite sitting area at the end. We are avid cooks and actually use a cutting board on top of the butcher block. At first I thought my husband was crazy, but after these many years of use, we would not be able to plane down the counter top as we could the cutting board. I love the look and the feel of it and in a pinch I can cut on it- but we save the heavy prep for the actual cutting board so it stays nice and flat.
PRO
DENVER R.E.S
8 years ago
I do not agree about the cons of solid wood. The City of Venice is still standing on wood for crying out loud! Wood is easy to care for and easy to clean, it is also incredibly durable. And wood is SAFER than plastic cutting boards!

http://www.nytimes.com/1993/02/10/health/wooden-cutting-boards-found-safer-than-plastic.html
elayna
7 years ago
What is the best kind of wood to use on a center island with a under mount sink and is an apron sink better seeing that it is not surrounded by wood?
PRO
Joseph Corlett, LLC
7 years ago
You'd better be a very fastidious wiper if you've got an undermount sink in any wood top.

Sponsored

More Discussions

suggestions to decorate empty wall space with ac unit

0

Kitchen Redesign

3

Help with kitchen layout

1

Rimu Kitchen, help!

3

Pergola company recommendations

0